Bunny invites Caroll to stay in Sybil's room without consulting the others, which upsets Jerry. Caroll reveals he is in love with Bunny, surprising him. Later, Caroll kisses Bunny before leaving, and Mindy sends them a disco ball for their home gym, leading to a scene where Bunny and Caroll dance in the empty room under the disco ball's light.

The show depicts events four months after Sybil's death, focusing on the characters dealing with her absence. Bunny wants to convert Sybil's room into a gym, and Mindy reminisces while going through Sybil's belongings with Arthur. The series also includes an episode titled 'Here’s to you Mrs Schneiderman' that serves as a memorial for Sybil, reflecting the real-life passing of actress Linda Lavin.

Mason, a Mormon man who left his bride at the altar, arrives in Palm Springs and asks Jerry if he can stay. Jerry agrees immediately, which upsets Bunny. Mindy convinces Mason to return and talk to the woman he left at the altar, resolving his storyline.

When Mindy learns about Caroll and Mason staying at the house, Bunny, Arthur, and Jerry tell her that she reminds them of Sybil. They also clarify to Caroll that Bunny is not interested in him, showing their protective and candid nature regarding their relationships.

Mindy helps the group navigate the changes after Sybil's death by going through Sybil's things with Arthur and mediating between characters like Mason and Caroll. She declines the offer to take over Sybil's room but supports Bunny and Caroll by sending them a disco ball for their new gym, symbolizing her ongoing connection to the group.