In episode 9, Coop is preparing for a potential life behind bars and is seen transferring his half of the house deed to Mel as a defensive move. Mel confronts Coop about his attitude and decisions, showing tension between them. Ali is dealing with unresolved issues involving Bruce and Sam, revealing she has been off her medication and engaging in risky behavior, which affects her performance at a bar. Coop insists Ali needs to get back on her meds, highlighting their strained relationship. Meanwhile, Coop is grappling with his legal troubles and the possibility of imprisonment, which affects his interactions with others around him.

The episode reveals that Paul Levitt's death was not a straightforward murder but involved a complex setup, including Paul's suicide and Sam's scheme to frame Coop. This twist flips the entire story on its head, showing that Coop is not just a victim but becomes a vigilante figure by the end. The episode also uncovers Sam's hidden motives and Coop's transformation, which are central to the finale's impact.

Coop starts the episode resigned to the possibility of going to prison, adopting a new perspective on his situation. He transfers his assets to Mel to protect his family's financial security and initially plans to fight his case but later considers a plea bargain. By the end, Coop embraces a new identity as a professional thief, negotiating a lucrative deal with his former employers but ultimately choosing to walk away from the opportunity, signaling a significant personal transformation and liberation from his past.

The episode emphasizes themes of deception, social façades, and reinvention. Coop's changing perspective and his final decision to leave the gala early symbolize his break from his former life. The title itself reflects how events and relationships in the story become laden with symbolic meaning and irony, such as Coop's forgiveness of Sam contrasted with his lingering grudge against Mel, and the public unraveling of private dramas like Ali's onstage confession. These elements underscore the show's exploration of personal and social complexities.

The episode leaves open the future of Coop and Mel's relationship, with Mel deciding to fly solo for a while but the door left open for a reunion. Coop's new career path as a professional thief and his choice to walk away from a major deal suggest ongoing personal and professional challenges. The true extent of Sam's schemes and the fallout from Paul's death also remain areas for further exploration. These unresolved threads set the stage for continued drama and character development in Season 2.