Episode 6 reveals that Hub killed Cheryl Dawson by mistake during a drunken altercation with Lucky. Hub was guilt-ridden and covered up the evidence by burying Cheryl's body. Lucky suspected Hub but could never prove it, which led to Lucky commissioning an attempt on Hub's life.

Lucky captures Hub and tortures him by breaking his fingers with a hammer to force a confession on camera. Before Lucky can succeed, two Slypharis demons break in and attack Lucky, allowing Hub to break free and kill the demons with a shotgun and chainsaw.

Maryanne refuses to lie to protect Hub initially but later lies to Sheriff Ruby to cover for him. She and Cade return to town to warn Hub about the sheriff's suspicions. Despite Hub's frustration, Cade insists on standing by him, and together with Maryanne, they help organize a cleanup and prepare to face the dangers ahead.

Sheriff Ruby grows suspicious of the Halloran family, especially Maryanne, after obtaining security footage showing Maryanne and Hub together. She questions Kitty and contacts Maryanne in Nashville, tricking her into lying, which confirms Maryanne's involvement in the unfolding events.

Kitty finds the accident wreckage and learns from the police that a body has been found—the hostage who was to be sacrificed by the demons has been ritualistically murdered. Kitty then tends to Hub's wounds after he kills the demons, showing her concern and active involvement in the crisis.