The two main characters, both named Zack, have distinct traits and struggles. Zack #1 (Max Talisman) is a plus-sized hopeful fantasy author with a big personality and self-doubts about his unpublished novel. Zack #2 (Joey Pollari) is an aspiring talent agent stuck as an assistant to an exploitative boss, dealing with anxiety and low self-confidence despite being conventionally attractive. Both struggle with self-worth, which is the main obstacle to their relationship.

Their romance is depicted as tentative and unlikely, marked by a series of meet-cutes that often go awry due to their insecurities and self-doubts. The relationship is more about their personal struggles with self-worth than just their being gay men, making it a quintessentially queer love story. The film balances witty banter, sentiment, setbacks, and misunderstandings without relying on deception or gimmicks.

Ava, played by Jackie Cruz, is a co-worker and supportive friend to Zack #2. She provides comic relief and sharp dramatic moments, often calling out Zack Mandel's self-centeredness and lack of curiosity about others. Although the film reveals she is a lesbian only at the end, her character underscores Zack Mandel's self-absorption and adds depth to the friend group dynamic.

New York City serves as a vibrant backdrop for the story, with cinematography capturing the city's pulse and energy. The setting complements the lively and chaotic friend group and the unfolding romantic comedy, enhancing the film's authentic and inclusive storytelling vibe.

The film embraces rom-com formulas with sharp dialogue, witty banter, and laugh-out-loud moments, such as a chaotic date scene. It balances humor and heart, with an upbeat score and a lively ensemble cast. The tone is sincere and sweet, focusing on themes of finding family and self-acceptance within a queer context.